Homemade Butter Mints Recipe for the Perfect Treat

There’s something undeniably nostalgic and refreshing about butter mints—those creamy, melt-in-your-mouth treats that combine smooth butter with a sweet, minty flavor. Whether you’re making them for a special occasion, as a gift, or simply to indulge in a homemade treat, these mints are the perfect balance of sweet, creamy, and minty goodness.

What makes this recipe so special is how simple it is to make. With just a few basic ingredients and a little bit of time, you’ll have a batch of butter mints that are smooth, flavorful, and downright addictive. Best of all, you can customize them with your preferred level of mintiness and even add a pop of color with food coloring to match any theme or occasion.

Let’s get started with the first few steps to make these delightful mints!

Step 1: Beat the Butter

Start by placing ½ cup unsalted butter in a large bowl. The butter should be softened to room temperature, which makes it easier to work with and ensures the mints turn out smooth and creamy.

Using a hand mixer or stand mixer, beat the butter until it’s smooth and creamy. This process usually takes about 1–2 minutes, and it’s important to do it well to ensure a smooth base for the mints.

Step 2: Gradually Add Powdered Sugar

Now that your butter is soft and creamy, it’s time to start adding the powdered sugar. You’ll want to add it gradually to avoid a sugary mess. Add ½ cup of powdered sugar at a time, mixing well after each addition.

Continue this process until you’ve added all 3 ½ cups of powdered sugar. Be patient, and make sure the sugar is fully incorporated before adding the next batch. This will help create a smooth, thick base that holds the mint flavor and texture together.

Step 3: Add Vanilla Extract and Milk

Once the sugar is fully mixed in, it’s time to add a touch of flavor and smoothness to the mints. Add 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract and 1 tablespoon of milk to the mixture. The vanilla adds a subtle sweetness, and the milk helps make the mixture smoother and easier to work with.

Mix until smooth and creamy—this will be your base flavor that will complement the peppermint extract you’ll add next.

Step 4: Add Peppermint Extract

Here’s where the minty magic happens. Add 1–2 tablespoons of peppermint extract to the mixture. Start with 1 tablespoon and taste it. If you want a stronger mint flavor, gradually add another tablespoon until you’ve reached the level of mintiness you desire. The peppermint extract will give these butter mints that refreshing kick, so adjust it to suit your taste.

Step 5: Add Food Coloring (Optional)

If you want to add a little fun and color to your mints, you can add a few drops of food coloring. This step is optional but highly recommended if you want to make your mints visually appealing for holidays, parties, or themed events. Just a few drops will go a long way in giving them a nice pastel color.

Mix well until the color is evenly distributed throughout the mixture.

Now that your butter mint mixture is smooth, minty, and perfectly colored, it’s time to shape them into the bite-sized treats that will melt in your mouth. The fun part is coming up—shaping and setting them to firm up!

Let’s dive into the next steps to get these mints ready to enjoy.

Step 6: Roll the Mixture into Small Balls

Start by rolling the mint mixture into small, even-sized balls, about the size of a marble. You can use your hands to roll the mints, or for a more uniform size, use a small cookie scoop or spoon.

Once rolled, place the mints onto a parchment-lined baking sheet to keep them from sticking. The parchment paper will also make cleanup a breeze, as the mints will be easy to remove once they’re firmed up.

Step 7: Shape with a Candy Mold or into Squares (Optional)

If you want your mints to have a more polished look, you can use candy molds to give them a specific shape. Simply press the mint mixture into the molds and release them once firm. Alternatively, you can skip the rolling step and press the mixture into a square shape and cut it into smaller squares with a knife or pizza cutter.

This is a great option if you want a uniform look or if you’re giving these as gifts and want them to look extra special.

Step 8: Refrigerate the Mints to Firm Up

Once your mints are shaped, refrigerate them for at least 30 minutes to allow them to firm up. Chilling them helps the butter mints hold their shape, so they have that perfect melt-in-your-mouth consistency once you bite into them.

If you’re planning to make these ahead of time, you can refrigerate them for several hours or overnight to ensure they’re nice and firm before serving.

Step 9: Store the Mints

After your butter mints have set and firmed up, transfer them to an airtight container for storage. Store them in the refrigerator, where they will stay fresh for up to 2 weeks.

If you want to make a big batch to give away or store for later, these mints freeze well too. Just place them in a freezer-safe container, and they will keep in the freezer for up to 3 months. To enjoy, simply let them thaw at room temperature for a few minutes.

FAQ + Final Thoughts on Homemade Butter Mints:

Now that your Homemade Butter Mints are chilled, firmed up, and ready to be enjoyed, let’s take a look at some frequently asked questions to help you with any adjustments or tips for perfecting these treats. Plus, we’ll wrap things up with a final note on why these butter mints are bound to become your go-to sweet treat.

1. Can I use a different extract besides peppermint?
Yes! While peppermint is the traditional flavor for butter mints, you can definitely get creative. You could try:

• Spearmint extract for a milder mint flavor
• Vanilla extract if you prefer a sweeter, subtler taste
• Almond extract for a nutty, aromatic twist
• Cinnamon or wintergreen extract for a spicier option

Just keep in mind that the amount of extract needed may vary depending on the strength of the flavor.

2. Can I make these mints without food coloring?
Absolutely! The food coloring is entirely optional. If you prefer to keep them simple and all-natural, just skip the food coloring and let the creamy, buttery color of the mints shine. You can still enjoy the same delicious flavor without the added color.

3. How do I make the mints more firm if they don’t set properly?
If your mints are too soft, you can refrigerate them for a bit longer. If they still don’t firm up as desired, try adding a small amount of extra powdered sugar (a tablespoon at a time) to the mixture and re-chill. However, don’t overdo it, as this could affect the texture.

4. How can I make these mints more festive for the holidays or parties?
To make your mints look extra festive:

• Use holiday-themed candy molds (stars, hearts, or seasonal shapes) for a special touch.
• Add a bit of edible glitter or sprinkles for sparkle.
• For a holiday twist, you could swap the peppermint for cinnamon or gingerbread flavoring to match the season.

5. Can I store these mints at room temperature?
While it’s best to store them in the refrigerator to keep them firm and fresh, they can be kept at room temperature for short periods (a day or two) without much problem. If left out for too long, they may soften, so it’s best to keep them cool until you’re ready to serve or gift them.

6. Can I make a sugar-free version of these mints?
Yes, you can make a sugar-free version by swapping out the powdered sugar for a suitable sugar substitute like confectioners’ erythritol or stevia powder. Keep in mind that the texture might differ slightly, but the flavor will still be enjoyable. If you’re using a sugar substitute, be sure to follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for proper conversion ratios.

Final Thoughts on Homemade Butter Mints:

These Homemade Butter Mints are the perfect combination of creamy, sweet, and minty goodness. Whether you’re preparing them for a special event, gifting them to friends and family, or simply indulging in a batch of homemade treats, these mints are sure to impress. They’re easy to make, require just a few simple ingredients, and can be customized to suit your tastes, making them a go-to recipe for any occasion.

What I love most about these mints is how versatile they are. You can adjust the flavoring, color, and even shape them to fit any theme or celebration. Plus, they make for a thoughtful homemade gift that anyone would appreciate—especially during the holidays or at birthday parties.

Tried the recipe? I’d love to hear how it went! Did you experiment with any fun variations or color schemes? Share your experiences and let me know how you made these butter mints your own. Enjoy these creamy, minty treats, and happy making!

Print